The Mental Edge for Trend Following: Confidence Is the Lack of Fear

Confidence: The Mental Edge

“Originally all of our testing was done mechanically with pencil and graphs that [we] turned into Lotus spreadsheets. …[still today] we use [this] extensively in a lot of our day to day work.”
Tom Bozarth
Formerly of John W. Henry & Co.

Most traders are conditioned to respond over and over again in the same way to the same experiences. They choose what makes life familiar and comfortable. They don’t need to maintain a mental edge since nothing changes for them. What can be done?

Instead of looking for commonalities in the market, look for what every successful trader has in common. Every trader who has broken through to sustained success in the market has a common characteristic: Confidence. In other words, no matter how good you are at analyzing the market, if you don’t have confidence, all you’re really doing is repeatedly creating experiences to which you will respond with similar frustration and anxiety.

How do you achieve confidence? You gather knowledge and practice discipline. The more you learn about the markets and your approach to trading the markets, the more effective you become as a trader. The more effective you become, the less fearful you are. Confidence is the lack of fear. That’s it. Lack of fear. When you are confident, you can win.

Ask yourself:

  • How do you handle your emotions? Is there a process?
  • What is your perception of the world? How did you arrive there? Is it accurate?
  • Are you able to have the same emotion whether you win or lose?
  • Do past mistakes make you hesitant to pull the trigger today?
  • Do you have the belief system of a winner or loser?
  • Do you think in terms of probabilities?
  • Is the way you attach meaning to things too wrapped up in personal emotion?

No matter your profession the answers are critical for everyone.

The Bozarth quote at the top frames the entire discussion. John W. Henry’s firm began testing with pencil and paper and Lotus spreadsheets. Not Bloomberg terminals. Not supercomputer clusters. The mental edge that produced decades of systematic trading success was built on methodical, unglamorous process work: testing approaches, building conviction in the results, and following through with discipline. The confidence came from the work, not from external validation or market outcomes. That is the sequence the article describes: knowledge first, then effectiveness, then the reduction of fear that produces confidence.

The seven questions are worth sitting with honestly. The most important is probably the fourth: do past mistakes make you hesitant to pull the trigger today? A trader who hesitates on valid entries because of recent losses is carrying their trading history into decisions that should be made on current conditions alone. The current signal either meets the entry criteria or it does not. The previous loss is irrelevant to that evaluation. Hesitation rooted in past pain is the mechanism that causes traders to miss the large winning trades that justify the entire systematic approach.

Feedback

From reader, Robert Bassett (Jan 8, 2004):

This is a tremendous article, very truthful and to the point. I’ve been charting for about 15 years, it’s a labor of love for me. I spent a lot of time with a very successful trader in my first two years of learning. I felt undercapitalized, and as you know, that can lead to “fear” if one lets it happen. It’s amazing what I learned through all this time. But, as your article indicates, without confidence, this doesn’t amount to a hill of beans. The bottom line is will I ever act on the mountains of “experience” of charting and following the futures markets? Or will I remain buried under the avalanche that is created by lack of confidence? Here’s hoping your article is the first step in the digging out process to breaking through to the other side. Thanks.

From reader, James A. Boubong (Jan 8, 2004):

I learned this formula years ago while learning, then teaching golf. It holds true in all of life’s meaningful endeavors. In the last few years, I have employed it in my trading. Simply put: HABIT → CONSISTENCY → RELIABILITY → CONFIDENCE

Boubong’s formula from golf instruction is the practical roadmap that the article’s theory implies. Confidence is not the starting point. It is the endpoint of a process: build habits, develop consistency from those habits, build reliability from that consistency, and arrive at confidence as the natural result. The trader who is searching for confidence before they have built habits is searching in the wrong direction. The habits come first. The system defines the habits. Following the system consistently builds the reliability. The confidence arrives when the process has been executed enough times to demonstrate that it works.

Bassett’s feedback identifies the gap that experience alone cannot close. Fifteen years of charting and learning represents substantial knowledge. What it cannot supply is the willingness to act. That willingness, the confidence to pull the trigger on a valid signal without hesitation or second-guessing, is the product of Boubong’s formula applied to a specific systematic approach over a sufficient period. The knowledge is necessary but not sufficient. The habit of executing the system, built through repeated application, produces the confidence that knowledge alone does not.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the mental edge in trend following?

Confidence, defined as the lack of fear. Confidence is not bravado or certainty about outcomes. It is the absence of the fear that causes hesitation, second-guessing, and emotional override of valid signals. It is produced by gathering knowledge about the approach and practicing the discipline of following it, which builds effectiveness, which reduces fear, which produces confidence.

How do past mistakes affect trading performance?

By creating hesitation on future valid entries. A trader who was hurt by a recent loss enters the next trade with diminished conviction, which makes them more likely to exit early or size down below the system’s prescribed level. Both responses reduce the expected value of the trade below what the system would produce if followed with full conviction. Past mistakes belong in the system review process, not in the real-time trading decision.

What is the HABIT to CONFIDENCE formula?

Habit produces consistency. Consistency produces reliability. Reliability produces confidence. The formula, adapted from golf instruction, describes how confidence is built through process rather than through outcomes. You do not start with confidence. You build habits by following the system, develop consistency from repeated habit execution, arrive at reliability when the process has been executed enough times to demonstrate its properties, and find confidence as the natural result of that reliability.

Trend Following Systems
Want to learn more and start trading trend following systems? Start here.